Are Copilot Notebooks any good?

Key insights

• Copilot Notebooks are Microsoft’s new tool for collecting references to files, Copilot pages, and other links across the M365 ecosystem. They launched in early 2025 as a competitor to Google’s NotebookLM.
  
• The notebooks offer an interactive environment that helps users work with AI-powered features. People can explore data, test ideas, and create prototypes without needing deep technical knowledge.
  
• Integration with other Microsoft tools is a key feature. Copilot Notebooks connect smoothly with apps in the Microsoft suite, making it easier for users to manage workflows without switching between platforms.
  
• Enhanced productivity is a main benefit. Users can quickly validate ideas and use AI tools directly within the notebook interface, saving time and effort.
  
• The platform uses a low-code approach, making it accessible for beginners while still supporting advanced professionals. This helps more people use AI in their daily work.
  
• Innovative features, such as multi-agent orchestration and Microsoft 365 Copilot Tuning, allow organizations to customize AI models and enable different agents to collaborate on complex tasks within the notebook environment.
  

Introduction: Microsoft’s Copilot Notebooks Enter the Scene

In the first half of 2025, Microsoft released its much-anticipated Copilot Notebooks, aiming to rival Google’s NotebookLM and further expand its AI-driven productivity suite. Darrell Webster, known as the Modern Work Mentor, explores whether these notebooks deliver on their promise in his latest YouTube video. As part of the growing Microsoft 365 Copilot ecosystem, Copilot Notebooks are designed to help users collect references from files, Copilot pages, and various links across the Microsoft 365 environment. This release marks a significant milestone in Microsoft's broader strategy to integrate artificial intelligence into daily business operations.

While this tool is still in its early stages, it is already clear that Copilot Notebooks are intended to boost productivity and streamline workflows. However, questions remain about how well the feature works in practice and whether it lives up to user expectations. Let’s take a closer look at the core features, the advantages, and some of the challenges highlighted in Webster’s walkthrough.

Understanding the Basics: Features and Integration

At its core, Copilot Notebooks offer a flexible, interactive space for users to harness Microsoft’s AI tools. Users can create a notebook, add instructions, and reference files or Copilot pages with ease. The interface is designed to be intuitive, making it accessible even for those without a technical background. By allowing users to gather information and resources in one place, Copilot Notebooks offer a streamlined approach to managing complex projects.

Integration with the broader Microsoft 365 suite is a key advantage. Users can link documents, chats, and other references directly into their notebooks, which helps keep related materials organized and easily accessible. This seamless connectivity is intended to minimize the friction of switching between multiple apps, allowing for a more focused workflow.

Productivity and Accessibility: A Double-Edged Sword

One of the most notable benefits highlighted in Webster’s review is the enhanced productivity that Copilot Notebooks offer. By enabling users to prototype ideas and validate concepts within a single environment, the tool significantly reduces the need to jump between different platforms. This can save valuable time and energy, especially for teams collaborating on complex tasks.

Moreover, the notebooks are built to be accessible to a broad audience. Thanks to their low-code design, even beginners can benefit from AI-powered insights without needing advanced coding skills. However, this simplicity comes with tradeoffs. While ease of use is a major draw, some advanced users may find the current feature set limiting compared to more specialized tools.

Innovative Developments: AI Integration and Multi-Agent Orchestration

With the introduction of Copilot Notebooks, Microsoft is pushing the boundaries of what interactive, AI-powered environments can achieve. New features such as Microsoft 365 Copilot Tuning allow organizations to customize AI models using their proprietary data, making the tool more adaptable to specific business needs. This flexibility stands out as a significant improvement over previous iterations of AI-powered notebooks.

Another notable development is the inclusion of multi-agent orchestration. This allows multiple AI agents to collaborate within the same notebook, handling more complex tasks and providing more nuanced insights. However, balancing the power of these features with ease of use remains a challenge. While advanced capabilities are exciting, ensuring that the interface remains user-friendly is crucial to widespread adoption.

Challenges and Tradeoffs: The Road Ahead

Despite its promise, Copilot Notebooks are not without their challenges. As Webster notes, the tool is still new, and there are areas where improvements are needed. For instance, while the integration with Microsoft 365 is robust, users may encounter occasional hiccups when linking certain types of files or chats. Additionally, the balance between accessibility and advanced functionality is delicate; as Microsoft adds more features, maintaining simplicity will require careful design decisions.

There is also the broader issue of user adoption. Introducing a new workflow tool can be disruptive, and organizations will need to invest time in training and change management. Nevertheless, Copilot Notebooks represent a bold step forward in democratizing AI for everyday business use, offering a glimpse into the future of collaborative, AI-driven workspaces.

Conclusion: A Promising Start with Room to Grow

In summary, Microsoft’s Copilot Notebooks offer an exciting new way to organize, reference, and leverage AI insights within the Microsoft 365 ecosystem. The tool’s accessibility, integration, and innovative features make it a strong contender in the AI productivity space. However, as with any new technology, there are tradeoffs and challenges that must be addressed for widespread adoption.

As organizations continue exploring the potential of Copilot Notebooks, Microsoft’s commitment to refining and expanding the tool will be crucial. With ongoing updates and user feedback, Copilot Notebooks are poised to become a valuable asset for teams looking to enhance productivity and embrace AI-powered collaboration.

Keywords

Copilot Notebooks review Copilot Notebooks features Copilot Notebooks benefits Copilot Notebooks performance Copilot Notebooks usability Copilot AI notebooks comparison best AI coding tools 2025